First Five Minutes: WoW vs CoH
March 23rd, 2009Deprecated: Function split() is deprecated in /home/jaxtrasi/www/wp-content/plugins/google-analytics-for-wordpress/googleanalytics.php on line 413
I wrote this in March 2008. To my knowledge, with the likely exception of the find-a-friend incentives, neither game has changed.
It seems to have become an accepted truth in the MMO community that you can’t compete with WoW. It has too much money thrown at it. Too much market share. Too much presence. Be happy fighting over the scraps, that’s what they say. But why is WoW successful, really? Because it’s *good*. More importantly, it’s good right from the start, allowing time for the natural compulsive effect of character progression and community responsibility to kick in.
Let’s compare the first few hours of World of Warcraft with City of Heroes and see whether WoW comes out on top simply as a matter of budget, or whether there’s actually some (easily replicable) merit in there somewhere.
Read the rest of this entry »